When it comes to barbecue in Iowa City, and I mean real barbecue (none of that Buffalo Wild Wings crap), the choices are few and far between. In fact, to my knowledge, there are only two:
Jimmy Jack's Rib Shack and
The Pit Smokehouse. Now it's time for them to duke it out.
In order to judge the two, I ordered the food by which all barbecue restaurants should be judged: ribs.
Jimmy Jack's Rib Shack:
First, I went to
Jimmy Jack's Rib Shack, located at
1940 Lower Muscatine Dr. The menu doesn't offer a whole lot of choices. Click the link above to see it for yourself. If you go there, you

better be in the mood for barbecue because that's all you have to choose from. They've got a variety of barbecue sandwiches with various meats (and even a
portobello mushroom option), as well as ribs and chicken. They also offer some sides, including fries, a corn bread muffin, baked beans, coleslaw, chips, and a chocolate chip cookie for dessert.
A half-slab of ribs by itself costs 11.99, but a the half-slab dinner, which comes with corn bread and two additional sides cost $15.49. I got the dinner with the beans and the fries.
Let me just say this: Jimmy Jack's has some of the best ribs, fries, and cornbread I have ever had. I'm not one who enjoys rib whose meat falls right off the bone. I like them to stick a little bit, so that when you cut them, the meat doesn't slide off, leaving the bone completely bare. These ribs do just that. They're tender, juicy, incredibly meaty, and come off the bone only when you bite into them.
For the ribs, you have your choice of four different barbecue sauces: the regular, the 4-alarm, the cowboy, and the Carolina mustard. While they were all delicious, I have to say that the cowboy was my favorite. It's sweet and smoky and the perfect compliment to the meat, though the spicy 4-alarm is a close second.

Like I said, Jimmy Jack's also has some of the best fries and cornbread I've ever had. Everything they give you comes in huge portions. They give you a bunch of huge, steak cut, ultra fried and crispy fries. Oh, how I love crispy fries. They're a beautiful golden brown and as far as I'm concerned, no other fry can compete. The cornbread is great and huge as well. It's sweet and full of flavor.
The restaurant itself is spacious and clean. They even have a nice outdoor patio, though it backs up to Lower Muscatine Dr., it's still a nice place to eat in the non-winter months.
Basically, I love this place. Now I just had to see if The Pit could compete.
The Pit Smokehouse:
The Pit Smokehouse lies just outside of downtown Iowa City at
130 N. Dubuque St. It's a

convenient spot, especially on those last weekend nights since The Pit is open until 3am Friday and Saturday. It's a smaller place with a difficult parking lot, but I wasn't too worried about that. I was there for the food.
The first thing I noticed was a
noticeably larger menu. Here's both parts of the menu so you can see for
yourself:
Part 1,
Part 2. They've got everything that Jimmy Jack's has, plus more desserts, salads, burgers, hot dogs, and a list of "Fried Goodies".
I was surprised to see that there are no combo-style dinner options. Every thing on menu is separate.
The half-slab is less than Jimmy Jack's, at $9.75. If I had wanted to match the Jimmy Jack's dinner, it would be another $2 for the fries, $1.75 for the beans, and $1.25 for the cornbread. That's $14.75, which is about $0.75 less than Jimmy Jack's. I opted for the half-slab with just fries and cornbread.
The ribs were less than spectacular. The top of the rib meat was dry and tough while the rest effortlessly slid right of the bone. So while some of the meat was dry, the rest was a little too slimy. There was very little middle ground between the two. They also lacked the meaty factor that Jimmy Jack's perfected so well. They were an overall disappointment.
There are only two sauce options: House and Spicy. The House is sweet and overall pretty good, while the Spicy is just the House with more pepper.
The fries are big and crinkle cut. I'm a fan of the crinkle cut, and these fries were pretty good. The portion of fries was big and hearty, but they weren't as good or unique as Jimmy Jack's.
The cornbread was good, but nothing special. It tasted fine, but could never live up to the standards set by my previous cornbread experience.
Conclusion:
Jimmy Jack's is the clear-cut winner. The food was simply outstanding. The ribs, the sides, and the sauces were some of the best I've had. And unless you're a really tightly wound penny pincher, you won't mind dishing out an additional $0.75 for better food and bigger portions.
I'm not saying I won't return to The Pit, just not for their barbecue. I would like to try a burger or hot dog, but that's for another blog. For now, just get to Jimmy Jack's get ready to have a full belly and a plate of leftovers.